There are several threads on SCoA about peeling clearcoat on a small number of cars.
Several have reported that their 09 Rally Red cars in some instances, the clear coat has started to peel or delaminate. I have personally observed this on one rally red vehicle. My wife has an 09 rally red Pure and so far the clear coat has not delaminated. It has been suggested that you contact smart USA on their Facebook page, tell them your concern and provide your vin. #. They are supposed to contact you after posting this info. on their FB page.
You need to call smartUSA directly, not the dealer or smart Center. Open up a case & have one of their field reps inspect your vehicle. The telephone # is on a sticker affixed to the inside of the driver's side sun visor.
My wife's '09 rally red passion makes yours look like it's in pristine condition, there's no clearcoat at all on the access cover. There's peeling on all panels except the right rear, that's the one that got replaced in an accident.
I too have a 2009 Passion Cabriolet Red in color. I have a bout 70 percent clear coat peeled on the front and rear right side of the car. The font panel behind the license plate is also peeled pretty bad. I have already replaced the hood myself. All the other panels are peeling to some extent. I contacted Smart USA and they had the dealer contact me. I took the vehicle in for them to check it. They later contacted me and offered 10 percent off of the labor and new panels I needed at that time. Cost of panels and labor was about $1000.00 to $1100.00 and they offered $100.00 off.
I too have an '09 Rally Red smart with peeling panels. I have been backing and forthing with smartUSA and my dealer for over a year now and there still is no resolution. My dealer (Mercedes Benz of Bloomfield Hills) hasn't a clue. I was asked to bring my car in for an inspection after contacting MB USA about the problem, yet the dealer had no knowledge of the request and simply told me I needed to buy new panels. I explained what the problem was and who had asked me to bring the car in, still nothing. I have opened a case with smartUSA and I was to be contacted back, yet I am still waiting. There is obviously a problem with the clearcoat on some '09 Rally Red smarts. This is a manufacturers defect....I am not asking for a new car...fix the problem....you have offered others a repaneling of the car for the cost of the labor ($500)...check out the over 350 posts regarding this problem on smartcarofamerica.com