Less than a month after replacing my original windshield (small chip developed into a 15 inch vertical crack from just under the drivers side wiper) - while driving on the 91 Freeway in Corona, CA - a small piece of debris hit the upper passenger side. By the sound of the impact I didn't think much about it - then noticed a dime size star chip! I freaked! Within five days (after sitting in the sun for an afternoon) a crack has appeared - about 18 inches horizontal across to the mid point of the windshield. My insurance does not cover glass breakage - so it looks like another out of pocket trip to the dealer.

I am beginning to think that smart (MB) may be using a poor quality of glass material in the smart windshields. To save weight? Other reasons?

I have owned many MB's and BMW's in the last 30 years - experienced many debris hits to windshields from mild sounding to startling and have replaced only one windshield due to cracking - on a car with over 140 thousand miles! Never on a car with only 8000 miles on the odometer.

Does anyone else think that the quality of the glass in smart windshields is less than it should be? Sorry to say - but if the windshield cracks a third time - it might be time to rethink owning a smart.

Views: 19

Comment

You need to be a member of smart USA insider to add comments!

Join smart USA insider

Comment by Robert Stout on September 9, 2009 at 2:43pm
An inconsiderate,wanabee Arizona cowboy in a pickup with on/off highway tires, without mudflaps,stoned my windshield... Luckily , I have full glass coverage as the OEM windshield alone is $373....The position and slant of the windshield suggests this will not be the last time...FULL GLASS COVERAGE FOR SMART OWNERS IS SMART....
Comment by SandraK on May 24, 2009 at 10:26pm
My windshield was hit by a rock on the left-hand edge in Arizona last summer, and by the time I got back to Chicago, the crack was a quarter of the way across the width of the pane just below driver's eye level. At least the insurance company recognized that this was a special type of installation, and approved it going to the dealer, but, it still cost me a hefty deductible. But, at least my bill was only $750 total, not the amount Max got hit with! The wierdest thing was that -- since they needed to keep the car overnight-- they gave me a Mercedes sedan loaner for the day. It felt like a big, smooth-sailing boat after little smartie on all those bumpy, pot-holed Chicago roads! Anyhow, good luck with yours--hope the last time WAS the last time for this problem.
Comment by Max on May 24, 2009 at 9:09pm
I caught a rock in the center of my windshield on I-40 about two weeks ago and it was not the sound of the rock that shocked me..........it was the bill. Try $874.00!
Comment by Saundra on May 23, 2009 at 10:41pm
I had something hit my window from a semi about 3 weeks ago, upper passenger side......LOUD! Scared me.

Think I saw your original window post so I have kept looking at the roof, the part between the roof and glass but no mark, no crack. Still surprised I did not have damage. Sorry to hear about your second crack...........not sure what to think about the glass because we have opposite situations.
Comment by grwhitaker on May 23, 2009 at 10:25pm
I don't think it is the smart-it is the 91 FWY. I have had several vehicles badly damaged from road debris on the 91 from OC to Riverside. My SUV lost two windshields-one to a truck wheel chock that bounced off from underneath the trailer of an 18 wheeler, and another from a chunk of pavement. The 91 FWY seems to be worst than most in SoCal for flying major debris.
Comment by Ryan on May 23, 2009 at 5:46pm
You also have to remember that the glass in the smart is a little more vertical than the windshield of most other cars, and would be more prone to taking a direct hit from something, which would much easier cause a crack than a glancing blow.

find a

smart center

go

Photos

Loading…
  • Add Photos
  • View All

Videos

  • Add Videos
  • View All

© 2014   Mercedes-Benz USA, LLC.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service